Odds & predictions Upcoming matchups No upcoming game is scheduled. Recent results and the experts who know these teams are below.
Feb 3, 2026 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 New York Islanders 5 Final/OT Oct 9, 2025 New York Islanders 3 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 Final Dec 29, 2024 New York Islanders 2 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 Final Dec 28, 2024 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 New York Islanders 6 Final Nov 5, 2024 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 New York Islanders 4 Final/SO Apr 17, 2024 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 New York Islanders 5 Final Feb 20, 2024 New York Islanders 5 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 Final/OT Dec 31, 2023 New York Islanders 1 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 Final Dec 27, 2023 Pittsburgh Penguins 7 New York Islanders 0 Final Mar 9, 2023 New York Islanders 4 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 Final/OT Feb 20, 2023 New York Islanders 4 Pittsburgh Penguins 2 Final Feb 17, 2023 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 New York Islanders 5 Final Dec 27, 2022 Pittsburgh Penguins 1 New York Islanders 5 Final Apr 14, 2022 New York Islanders 3 Pittsburgh Penguins 6 Final Apr 12, 2022 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 New York Islanders 5 Final/SO Nov 26, 2021 Pittsburgh Penguins 1 New York Islanders 0 Final May 26, 2021 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 New York Islanders 5 Final May 24, 2021 New York Islanders 3 Pittsburgh Penguins 2 Final/2OT May 22, 2021 Pittsburgh Penguins 1 New York Islanders 4 Final May 20, 2021 Pittsburgh Penguins 5 New York Islanders 4 Final May 18, 2021 New York Islanders 1 Pittsburgh Penguins 2 Final May 16, 2021 New York Islanders 4 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 Final/OT Mar 29, 2021 New York Islanders 1 Pittsburgh Penguins 2 Final Mar 27, 2021 New York Islanders 3 Pittsburgh Penguins 6 Final Feb 28, 2021 Pittsburgh Penguins 0 New York Islanders 2 Final Feb 27, 2021 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 New York Islanders 3 Final/OT Feb 20, 2021 New York Islanders 2 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 Final Feb 18, 2021 New York Islanders 1 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 Final Feb 11, 2021 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 New York Islanders 3 Final/SO Feb 6, 2021 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 New York Islanders 4 Final Nov 21, 2019 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 New York Islanders 4 Final/OT Nov 19, 2019 New York Islanders 5 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 Final/OT Nov 7, 2019 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 New York Islanders 3 Final Apr 16, 2019 New York Islanders 3 Pittsburgh Penguins 1 Final Apr 14, 2019 New York Islanders 4 Pittsburgh Penguins 1 Final Apr 12, 2019 Pittsburgh Penguins 1 New York Islanders 3 Final Apr 10, 2019 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 New York Islanders 4 Final Dec 10, 2018 Pittsburgh Penguins 2 New York Islanders 1 Final Dec 6, 2018 New York Islanders 2 Pittsburgh Penguins 6 Final Nov 1, 2018 Pittsburgh Penguins 2 New York Islanders 3 Final Oct 30, 2018 New York Islanders 6 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 Final Mar 20, 2018 Pittsburgh Penguins 1 New York Islanders 4 Final Mar 3, 2018 New York Islanders 2 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 Final Jan 5, 2018 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 New York Islanders 0 Final Dec 7, 2017 New York Islanders 3 Pittsburgh Penguins 4 Final Mar 24, 2017 New York Islanders 4 Pittsburgh Penguins 3 Final Expert grades weight verified head-to-head profit at 75% and profit on other games involving either team at 25%, with a confidence adjustment until ten qualifying picks are recorded.
Oddsshark
Coolio
Covers
